Personaly i wouldint be happy with either, they should of gone for nabokov or giguere, or even another goalie, hasek = Old gerber = Playoff Choker

WEll i'm a Sens fan and I think it;s to early to start Downing Gerber.

I have to say I didn't want HAsek back, and i'm not a huge fan of gerber, but he hasn't reely been tested in the playoffs,
There was more reasons he did get pulled, he was sick and lost almost 20 pounds, I know I wouldn;t be able to play well after losing that much weight.

I also think that if Gerber doesn't play that well again in the playoffs then it is ok, Emery proved this year that he can be a playoff goaile he wasn;t the reason that the sens got knocked out, the wheren;t physical enough and need a more balanced D core.

I also think that 3 years for Gerber is too much. Emery really only needs one more year, mabye 2 before he steps into the #1 spot.

i think it was time for hasek to leave and give him some more time to heal. i think that it's about time for hasek to retire anyways. the older he gets, the more prone he'll get to injuries, my opinion.

Of course Gerber was a disaster in the playoffs. Even the best goalie in the world wouldn't play good if he had a stomach virus and had lost 10lbs. Gerber was on iv before game 1 against Montreal, the only thing that kept him wanting to play was his extreme competitiveness. He was sick and had lost his confidence but by next playoffs you can bet he'll be ready to prove something.