I think he is good.. is he really that overrated though?

I can't stand Shane Doan. He may be a good player, but he is also a master of the cheap shot. As an example, look no further than the last game against L.A. this year. In the last few seconds of the game, Doan checked an L.A. player into Mathieu Garon...totally uncalled for.

And last year against Anaheim, Doan sucker punched Vitaly Vishnevski AFTER the buzzer had went. He broke Vishnevski's nose and started an all out line brawl.

i did'nt know that... i just lost 50 percent respect for him... Nagy?..

I don't know very much about Nagy to be honest. Although I recall him being easily flustered by hard hits. He then tries to take matters into his own hands, which usually ends up backfiring on him badly.

Keep in mind that I rarely watch Phoenix (usually only when they play Anaheim).