QNHL.com - Quality NHL Hockey Forums

I didn't see another thread like this so i decided it would be good to make one.
Fell free to critque my post or post your own list.

1.Lidstrom
2.Pronger
3.Neidermeyer
4.Redden
5.Chara
6.Zubov
7.Ohlund
8.Stuart
9.Jovo
10.Regher

I agree for Lidstrom to be on first place,but what abaout Schinder (DET),Timmonen (NAS), Zdilicky (NAS),they r also great defensmans!!

Timmonen and Zidlicky would probably be around 15-20 and schnedier wouldn't even make my top 30

IMO

1.Lidstrom
2.Niedermeyer
3.Pronger
4.Redden
5.jovanovski
6.Chara
7.Zubov
8.Ohlund
9.Blake
10.Regher

I agree for most part with that list excet blake because he didn't have a very good year this year, and he can only do worse next year because he is aging.

Regehr should be higher on these lists. Jovo ahead of Regehr and Chara? No way.

1. Lidstrom
2. Neidermayer
3. Pronger
4. Chara
5. Redden
6. Regehr
7. Ohlund
8. Zubov
9. Hannan
10. Jovo

HM: Markov, Phaneuf, Kaberle

1. Lindsrtom
2. Nidermayer
3. Zubov
4. Schneider
5. Redden
6. McCabe
7. KAberle
8. CHara
9. Regher
10. Jovanovski

Pronger isn't a top 10 defensemen *rolls eyes.

i agree with that list..i'd put chara down a bit. i don't belive he's that good. also add jay mckee...st.louis gave 4million reasons why he's one of the best.

1. Nicklas Lidstrom
2. Scott Niedermayer
3. Chris Pronger
4. Sergei Zubov
5. Zdeno Chara
6. Wade Redden
7. Tomas Kaberle
8. Rob Blake
9. Mattias Ohlund
10. Brian Rafalski
11. Joni Pitkanen
12. Dion Phaneuf
13. Robyn Regehr
14. Andrei Markov
15. Bryan McCabe
16. Pavel Kubina
17. Scott Hannan
18. Kimmo Timonen
19. Lubomir Visnovsky
20. John-Michael Liles
21. Mathieu Schneider
22. Lubomir Visnovsky
23. Adam Foote
24. Ed Jovanovski
25. Brad Stuart
26. Jay Bouwmeester
27. Nicklas Kronwall
28. Marek Zidlicky
29. Adrian Aucoin
30. Christian Backman

HM: Dan Boyle, Sergei Gonchar, Barett Jackman, Sheldon Souray, Henrik Tallinder

*APPROXIMATE LIST*