Patrick Marleau does not need to be traded. but we do need a puck moving defensmen... here are some rumors going around



TO SJ:
Bryan McCabe


TO TORONTO:
Patrick Marleau




TO SJ:
Pavel Kubina
Bryan McCabe

TO TORONTO
Patrick Marleau
Kyle Mclaren
2nd round pick 08'


TO SJ:
Wade Redden

TO OTTAWA:
Patrick Marleau


TO SJ:
Wade Redden
Patrick Eaves/Antoine Vermette

TO OTTAWA:
Patrick Marleau
Christian Erhoff


TO SJ:
Matthias Ohland
Brendan Morrison

TO VANCOUVER:
Patrick Marleau
Christian Ehroff


san jose needs a second line center if they give up marleau, or need an even more solid defense. this way sharks gain benifits, as do all of the other teams

LOL no on ottawa would not trade Vermette and would not take eaves no way would leafs trade mccabe because he just signed a big contract with them maybe Marleau for Kubina big maybe and the vancouver deal wouldn't happen

mccabe has a no movement clause in his contract. he can't be traded if he doesn't want to leave Toronto. IMO, San Jose loses all of those deals. San Jose needs a defenseman to play DEFENSE, so McCabe is out of the question anyways.

lol you making fun of McCabe

i like mccabe, but you have to realize his limitations. he's got a great shot, awesome on the power play, but he makes mistakes in his own zone. SJ has enough offense that they need someone to help them out defensively. I think Carle can develop into the puck moving PP defenseman they need, so there isn't a need for McCabe.

yea but the mistakes McCabe makes Kaberle fixes them

Anybody who trades for McCabe would be losing in the deal. Apparantly the only place he is willing to waive his no-trade clause for is the Islanders.

sharks are looking for a strong defense and leadership through experienced defensmen

McCabe fits that for Ehroff, and Carle. then vlasic would follow kubina

also sharks can replace mccabe with kaberle

for ottawa they need to get a second line center to fill up marleau or pick up a defencmen close to volchencov, chris philips.....
and to top it of maybe chris neil for the third line to add grit to the line up

toronto wouldn't even look at that trade if kaberle was in it and toronto isn't going to trade mccabe just drop the toronto trade rumors

Bah. The Marleau rumors are always to Canadian teams. And they never stop. Canadian fans want Patty real bad...

I stopped listening to Marleau trade rumors a long time ago.

But Ehrhoff... who wants him? You can have him.

ChompBoard.com - San Jose Sharks Fan Forums & Message Boards & more